Joey's Olde World Pizza | Middletown NY, New York
Tony Boffa's Restaurant & Pizzeria | Middletown NY, New York
Colandrea Pizza King | Middletown NY, New York
The Only place for the best Pizza in Middletown NY, New York
Colandrea Pizza King | Middletown NY, New York
Your guide to the best Pizza in Middletown NY, New York
Best Pizza Middletown NY, New York
Tell a friend about this page
Colandrea Pizza King | Middletown NY, New York
Joey's Olde World Pizza | Middletown NY, New York
Tony Boffa's Restaurant & Pizzeria | Middletown NY, New York
Joey's Olde World Pizza | Middletown NY, New York
Tony Boffa's Restaurant & Pizzeria | Middletown NY, New York
Our top 3 picks for the best pizza places in Middletown NY, New York
Our top 3 picks for the best pizza Middletown NY New York
Editor's Choice
Editor's Choice
Pizza doesn't get any better then this!
Unlike Neapolitans or Chicagoans, New Yorkers embrace all kinds of pizza. From Roman-style pies with a cracker-thin crust to chewy, Sicilian slices, New York’s pizza restaurants serve whatever kind of pizza you want.

They’ve been making pizza here since the turn of the century with hand-tossed dough, light on the sauce. The classic New York pizza is baked in a coal-fired oven, which gives it a slightly smoky flavor.

You should fold your slice and avoid utensils. But however you eat it, it will likely be one of the best pizzas you‘ve ever tasted. Don’t leave the city until you try at least one slice.

The pizza places listed on this page are simply the best of Middletown NY, New York.
The best pizza places in Middletown NY, New York | www.bestpizzamiddletownnynewyork.com
Best Pizza Middletown NY New York | www.bestpizzamiddletownnynewyork.com
Colandrea Pizza King | Middletown NY, New York
Joey's Olde World Pizza | Middletown NY, New York
Tony Boffa's Restaurant & Pizzeria | Middletown NY, New York
Colandrea Pizza King
845-343-7275
Learn more
Joey's Olde World Pizza
845-344-0880
Learn more
Tony Boffa's Restaurant & Pizzeria
845-343-8842
Learn more
Editor's Choice for best pizza in Middletown NY New York | Tony Boffa's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Editor's Choice
Editor's Choice for best pizza in Middletown NY New York | Joey's Olde World Pizza
Editor's choice for best pizza in Middletown NY New York | Colandrea Pizza King
So what makes these pizza places the best?.... Simple, they all follow the same formula,

Great Food + Great People + Great Service + a Great Atmosphere = Great Pizza!!
Editor's Choice

Colandrea Pizza King
845-343-7275

Joey's Olde World Pizza
845-344-0880

Tony Boffa's Restaurant & Pizzaria
845-343-8842

More Great Pizza Places in Middletown NY

Marco's Pizza | 845-695-8700

Frank's Pizza and Restaurant | 845-342-6506

Franco Di Roma Italian Restaurant | 845-342-3552

Bada Bing Pizza & Pasta | 845-341-0000

Cosimo's Brick Oven Ristorante & Bar | 845-692-3242

Paesanos Pizza Restaurant | 845-343-2121

Carbonella's Coal Fire Pizza | 845-344-4499


Get listed here, Contact us today click here
Add this page to your favorites.
So if your looking for the best pizza in Middletown NY New York make sure they follow the same formula.

Great Food
Lets face it, if the food isnt good then whats the point? A great pizzeria should have great pizza and use only the finest, freshest ingredients and make their pizza's fresh. If you wanted to eat a pizza full of processed ingredients you would buy a frozen one out of the grocery aisle.

Great People & Great Service
The pizza place and staff should cater to their customers needs and always be friendly, curteous and provide great service to their customers. All while making their customers feel at home.

Great Atmosphere
The pizza place should be a fun place to go with friends and family. The atmosphere should be welcoming and feel like home. Not to mention the establishment should be clean, having a clean establishment shows that the owner and the workers take pride in their place and pizzeria.

There are many places that can claim they make the best pizza in the world. Honestly, it is really an individual issue. Pizza lovers are very loyal to the pizza they grew up with. Pizza fans are very particular about who makes the best pizza. It is a never ending argument. And you know, I would not have it any other way...

In my case...., the best pizza is made right here in Middletown NY New York! and i'm sure you'll agree.
Editor's Choice for best pizza in Middletown NY New York | Joey's Olde World Pizza
Editor's Choice for best pizza in Middletown NY New York | Tony Boffa's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Editor's choice for best pizza in Middletown NY New York | Colandrea Pizza King
Are you looking for the best pizza in Middletown NY, New York ? well then look no further because you have come to the right place. Thin crust or thick? Sicilian or Deep Dish? For many of us, pizza is a passion. If you want to call some nationwide chain for fast delivery of something that doesn't taste much better than the cardboard box it comes in, go right ahead. That means the wait will be shorter for the rest of us at the best Pizza Places below.So go ahead and check out our pizza picks below, You'll be glad you did.
Editor's Choice | Best Pizza in Middletown NY

The Best Pizza Middletown NY New York

Best Pizza Middletown NY New York

BestPizzaofMiddletown.com is also listed on these fine websites,